Tankless Water Heater Repair vs. Replacement: Which Option is Best for You in Warner Robins and MaconGA?

August 29, 2024

Tankless water heaters, a popular choice in Warner Robins and Macon, GA, are favored for their energy efficiency, space-saving design, and continuous hot water supply. However, like all machines, these units can develop issues over time, leaving homeowners with the decision of whether to repair or replace. In this dilemma, Buzzell Plumbing, a trusted company in the area, stands ready to assist. With their expert advice and reliable services tailored to your needs, they can help you make the best choice for your tankless water heater.


Understanding Tankless Water Heaters


Tankless water heaters, also called on-demand or instantaneous water heaters, work from old-school tank systems. These units store and heat water only sometimes. Instead, they use a gas burner or electric heating parts to warm the water as it passes through. This new approach has an impact on how we heat water and brings some perks such as:


  • Energy Efficiency: Tankless water heaters use energy when you need hot water. This removes the standby heat losses you get with tank-style units. This can mean big savings on energy bills for homes that don't use much hot water.
  • Longer Lifespan: If you take good care of them, tankless water heaters can work well for 20 years or more. That's almost twice as long as regular tank-style units last, providing you with long-term savings and peace of mind.
  • Continuous Hot Water Supply: Tank-style heaters can run out of hot water. But tankless units keep giving you hot water as long as you don't ask for more than they can handle. They don't have a set limit like tanks do.
  • Space-Saving Design: Wall-mounted tankless water heaters save space, making them a smart choice for homeowners who value space efficiency. They take up less room than traditional models, giving you more floor space in utility rooms or closets.Despite their advantages tankless water heaters can have problems. Common issues include mineral build-up, ignition failures, and system overload. These problems can impact how well the unit works and its efficiency.


When to Consider Repair


Sometimes, fixing a tankless water heater is the smartest and cheapest option. The team at Buzzell Plumbing knows how to spot and fix many issues. They can often make the unit last longer without replacing the whole thing. Here are some cases where they might suggest a repair:


  • Electrical Faults: Broken control boards, wire problems, or issues with sensors and thermostats often need specific fixes.
  • Clogged Filters or Vents: Filters and vents can get stuffed with junk over time, which limits water flow and proper air circulation. Cleaning and swapping out these parts by a pro can get things working right again.
  • Minor Component Malfunctions: Problems with single parts, like solenoid valves, gas control valves, or ignition assemblies sometimes just need a new part put in without changing the whole system.


When homeowners choose to repair in these cases, they can often make their tankless water heater last longer and avoid spending big money on a complete replacement right away.


Signs You Might Need a Replacement


Sometimes fixing things works, but other times you might need to get a whole new tankless water heater. The experts at Buzzell Plumbing can help you figure out when it's time to replace your heater. This way, you'll know you're making a smart choice and getting the most for your money. Here are some signs that might mean it's time to replace your heater:


  • Corroded Heat Exchanger: The heat exchanger plays a crucial role in a tankless water heater. When it gets corrupted or starts leaking, fixing it becomes impractical. In these situations, experts suggest getting a new one.
  • Major Water Leaks: Big water leaks from the unit's body or inside parts can be tough and expensive to fix. Buying a new unit might save you money and be a more dependable option in the long run.
  • End of Useful Life: Like other home appliances, tankless water heaters don't last forever. When your unit gets close to or goes past its expected lifespan (15-20 years), you might need to fix it often. Buying a new one makes more sense and saves you money in the long run.
  • Not Enough Hot Water: Maybe your family has grown, or you're using more hot water than before. If this happens, your tankless water heater might need to catch up. Getting a bigger or stronger unit ensures you always have enough hot water.


By tackling these problems head-on, you can stop bigger and more expensive damage to your home. You'll also get to use the newest tankless water heater tech advances.

Weighing Costs and Benefits


When choosing between fixing or swapping out a tankless water heater, you need to consider both short-term and long-term costs and perks. Repairs might look cheaper at first, but they can pile up over time if the unit is getting old. Conversely, a new heater can cost a lot upfront, but it can save you money and work better in the long run.

Tankless Water Heater

To guide homeowners in making a smart choice, the experts at Buzzell Plumbing will do a complete check of your current system looking at things like:


  • Age of the Unit: As tankless water heaters get older, replacing them becomes more cost-effective in the long run.
  • Warranty Coverage: A unit still under warranty might have repairs covered, which can reduce costs.
  • Household Hot Water Needs: If your current tankless water heater can't keep up with your family's hot water use or is too small, you might need to get a bigger or stronger replacement.
  • Energy Efficiency: New tankless water heaters often use less energy than old ones, which can lead to big savings on your utility bills over time.


By looking at these factors, Buzzell Plumbing's experts can give you a detailed breakdown of costs. This helps you figure out if fixing your water heater now will save you money or if getting a new one might be better in the long run.


What Buzzell Plumbing Can Do for You


At Buzzell Plumbing, we know that every home is different. We work hard to give you solutions that fit your needs. Here's what we offer:


  • Detailed Inspections: Our team of skilled technicians will closely examine your tankless water heater to spot any problems that need fixing.
  • Expert Repairs: If we decide to fix your heater, our technicians have the know-how to handle all sorts of issues, from swapping out small parts to tackling bigger repair jobs.
  • Full Replacements: Sometimes, getting a new heater is the best option. We offer many top-quality tankless water heaters from well-known brands. This ensures you get a unit that can meet your family's hot water needs and help you save on energy bills.
  • Professional Installations: Our certified experts will handle the setup process. They'll make sure your new tankless water heater fits right, gets put in, and is set up to work its best while saving energy.
  • Ongoing Maintenance: We offer full maintenance services to help your tankless water heater last longer and work better. This includes cleaning out buildup, flushing the system, and checking all the parts.


Choosing to fix or replace a tankless water heater is a big call that can affect your home's comfort, energy use, and overall expenses for years to come. To make a smart choice that fits your family's needs and budget, you should:


  1. Know the benefits of tankless water heaters
  2. Spot the signs that show you need to repair or replace
  3. weigh the costs and gains


At Buzzell Plumbing, our skilled team helps homeowners in Warner Robins and Macon GA, make this choice. We bring know-how, quality work, and a personal touch to offer solutions that fit your needs.


Can't decide whether to fix or swap out your tankless water heater? Buzzell Plumbing can guide you to the right choice for your home and wallet. Get in touch with us today for top-notch advice and service in Warner Robins and Macon GA

Mold growth on a light-colored surface, with patches of black and grey discoloration.
By Buzzell August 20, 2025
Mold is attracted to moisture, which can linger inside your ducts if there’s excess condensation. Oftentimes, this is the result of a leak within the ductwork.
A plumber in white gloves using a wrench to adjust a sink drain pipe under a black and white sink.
By Buzzell August 20, 2025
Although these items are commonly found in bathrooms, that doesn’t mean they should be flushed. These products don’t break down like toilet paper and can clogs.
A room with a water heater and a lot of pipes.
By Buzzell July 28, 2025
While it might be easy to brush it off, a noisy water heater should be taken seriously. Oftentimes, noises can indicate an underlying problem with your heater, and if left unaddressed, may have negative consequences.
A kitchen sink with a red plunger in it
By Buzzell July 28, 2025
Sinks that won't drain aren't just an inconvenience; they can create unsanitary conditions and potentially damage your plumbing system. Luckily, some of these plumbing problems can be remedied at home.
A man is working on a duct in the attic of a house.
By Buzzell June 20, 2025
As your duct system starts to break down, you tend to notice a decrease in comfort, and your HVAC system may also struggle to function efficiently. So, how can you tell when it's time to replace your ductwork? Keep an eye out for these warning signs:
A white sink with a faucet in a bathroom.
By Buzzell June 20, 2025
While it’s unpleasant to look at, this gunky buildup is surprisingly common in the South, particularly in central Georgia homes.
Two air conditioners are sitting outside of a building.
By Buzzell April 22, 2025
It’s incredibly important that homeowners in Georgia have air conditioning during the warmer months. If the AC unit stops working, the temperatures inside our homes can reach unsafe levels.
A close up of a drain with foam coming out of it.
By Buzzell April 22, 2025
Sewer line backups are a recurring problem for some Georgia homeowners during the Summer months. Because of the seasonal thunderstorms, extra rainwater can cause storm and sanctuary sewers to flood. The extra rainwater, combined with falling debris, can cause sewer line backups.
A water heater is attached to the side of a building.
By Buzzell April 22, 2025
Water heaters can last well into a decade, with some even lasting 20 years. So, it’s not a decision that’s taken lightly. Let us help you determine which one’s the best option by breaking down the two main types: tank and tankless water heaters. By evaluating their pros and cons, you’ll have a better idea of which is right for your home.
A close up of a drain on a tiled floor.
By Buzzell April 22, 2025
While a clogged shower drain is usually an easy fix, it's best to try and identify the cause. That way, we can prevent clogs from happening at all. Here are some common causes and solutions for a clogged shower drain.